Airline cards: when the annual fee pays for itself
An airline card pays for itself through its perks, not its miles on everyday spending. At the low values we count (about one round trip with a bag, plus anniversary points and credits), the perks cover the fee on 7 of the 16 airline cards we track. Each extra trip with a checked bag adds more. If you fly the airline less than once a year, a no-fee card usually earns more.
What pays the fee
- Free checked bags. On one round trip, a free first bag is worth $50 to $90 in our numbers, more if family on the same booking also checks a bag free.
- Companion fares. A second ticket for little or nothing, once a year. The Delta SkyMiles Platinum American Express Card gives a companion certificate after each renewal (see Is a Delta card worth it where you live?). The Atmos Rewards Ascent Visa Signature Card gives a $99 Companion Fare each anniversary (after $6,000 a year in purchases).
- Anniversary points. Some cards add points each year you keep the card.
Miles on everyday spending come second. Most airline cards earn 1 mile per dollar outside their bonus categories, which a no-fee card can match or beat.
Example: Southwest Plus or Premier
| Compare | Plus | Premier |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fee | $99 | $149 |
| Each anniversary | 3,000 anniversary points | 6,000 anniversary points |
| Worth about | $39 | $78 |
| Southwest purchases | 2x | 3x |
The math
Premier costs $50 more a year than Plus.
Its extra 3,000 anniversary points are worth about $39, at the 1.3 cents we count for each Southwest point.
That leaves $11. Premier's extra 1x on Southwest purchases covers it once you spend about $850 a year with Southwest.
Both give a free first checked bag. Plus earns 2x on gas and groceries on up to $5,000 a year; Premier earns 2x on groceries and dining on up to $8,000 a year. Pick the one that fits where you spend.
If you spend about $850 or more a year with Southwest, Premier comes out ahead. Below that, Plus is enough.
Every airline card we track
| Card | Annual fee | Perks we count a year |
|---|---|---|
| Citi AAdvantage MileUp Card | $0 | $0 |
| Delta SkyMiles Blue American Express Card | $0 | $0 |
| Atmos Rewards Ascent Visa Signature Card | $95 | $160 |
| Citi / AAdvantage Platinum Select World Elite Mastercard | $99 | $60 |
| Frontier Airlines World Mastercard | $99 | $100 |
| JetBlue Plus Card | $99 | $125 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Plus Credit Card | $99 | $129 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Premier Credit Card | $149 | $168 |
| Delta SkyMiles Gold American Express Card | $150 | $70 |
| United Explorer Card | $150 | $85 |
| Southwest Rapid Rewards Priority Credit Card | $229 | $187 |
| Delta SkyMiles Platinum American Express Card | $350 | $330 |
| United Quest Card | $350 | $305 |
| Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite Card | $395 | $115 |
| Delta SkyMiles Reserve American Express Card | $650 | $405 |
| Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard | $695 | $75 |
We count each perk at a low value, for about one round trip a year. Each extra trip with a checked bag adds to it.
When a no-fee card wins
If you fly the airline less than once a year, carry on only, or the airline does not fly nonstop from your city to the places you go, the perks are worth little to you. A no-fee card that earns 2% on everything likely earns more.
We compare your cards for every kind of purchase. Add your cards to the picker.
Sources
Card terms come from the issuers' own pages, checked on the date above. Terms change, so check the issuer before you apply.
- Southwest Rapid Rewards Plus Credit Card (creditcards.chase.com)
- Southwest Rapid Rewards Premier Credit Card (creditcards.chase.com)
- Citi AAdvantage MileUp Card (citi.com)
- Delta SkyMiles Blue American Express Card (americanexpress.com)
- Atmos Rewards Ascent Visa Signature Card (bankofamerica.com)
- Atmos Rewards Ascent Visa Signature Card, news release (newsroom.bankofamerica.com)
- Citi / AAdvantage Platinum Select World Elite Mastercard (citi.com)
- Frontier Airlines World Mastercard (cards.barclaycardus.com)
- JetBlue Plus Card (cards.barclaycardus.com)
- Delta SkyMiles Gold American Express Card (americanexpress.com)
- United Explorer Card (creditcards.chase.com)
- Southwest Rapid Rewards Priority Credit Card (creditcards.chase.com)
- Delta SkyMiles Platinum American Express Card (americanexpress.com)
- Delta SkyMiles Platinum American Express Card, more terms (americanexpress.com)
- United Quest Card (creditcards.chase.com)
- Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite Card (bankofamerica.com)
- Atmos Rewards Summit Visa Infinite Card, more terms (bankofamerica.com)
- Delta SkyMiles Reserve American Express Card (americanexpress.com)
- Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard (citi.com)